Frequently Asked Questions: Buchroeders Jewelers

No. One advantage of building a custom engagement ring is that you have control over the value-adding factors considering you have the ability to hand pick every single aspect of the engagement ring.

On the other hand, Buchroeders carries a carefully curated collection of in-house proposal-ready rings, fancy rings, and fine jewelry from some of the best designer names.

Buchroeders offers insurance on your purchased jewelry items via our own owned & operated in-house company Assurance Jewelry Protection. When you buy online or in-store, the option is available upon request, Don’t hesitate to contact us for further details.

Yes 100%. Our Gotta Love It Guarantee means we should have never let you leave our store in the first place! Any purchase from Buchroeders comes with a 30-day tryout period and if you’ve changed your mind for any reason, bring it in because our jewelry consultants want to make sure you leave happy and confident.

While we truly believe that word of mouth remains the most powerful form of recommendation, we’re always grateful when clients take a moment to share their experience online. If you’d like to go the extra mile, leaving a review on Google or Yelp would mean a great deal to our hardworking team. Thank you for your support!

Professional gemologists or certified jewelry appraisers evaluate jewelry at Buchroeders, for insurance, resale, or estate purposes.

Jewelry can be a good investment when it includes quality materials like gold, diamonds, or designer pieces that retain or grow in value. Heirloom jewelry often holds sentimental and financial worth, especially when crafted with high-purity metals or fine gemstones. While gold and silver prices can rise over time, they also fluctuate with the market, so timing matters when selling or using jewelry as collateral.

No, an engagement ring doesn’t have to be expensive—Buchroeders offers custom options to fit any budget without compromising on quality or style. Not only do custom engagement rings not have additional fees, but they often help maximize the size and quality of a piece based on an allotted budget.

Yes, engagement ring insurance is worth it to protect against loss, theft, or damage—and Buchroeders makes the process easy. Every engagement ring includes a complimentary appraisal to help you insure your ring through your preferred provider. Plus, with our Assurance Program, you receive zero-deductible coverage for eligible repairs and center-stone replacements, along with lifetime in-house services like cleanings, inspections, stone tightening, polishing, and resizing—keeping your ring protected and beautiful for years to come.

Lab-cultivated or man-made diamonds are conceived in a laboratory setting powered with state-of-art equipment that mimics similar conditions as earth-mined diamonds but in an exceptionally shorter timeframe. Natural diamonds are dug out deep from the earth’s mantle and require heavy manpower and machinery to be retrieved.

At Buchroeders, diamond pricing is based on rarity—not just beauty—and we believe in full transparency throughout the process. Our experts take the time to educate you on the 4 Cs of diamond quality—cut, color, clarity, and carat—so you understand exactly what you’re buying. While grading reports are important, we hand-select every diamond based on overall beauty, not just the numbers on paper. This approach ensures you get a visually stunning diamond with exceptional value, rather than overpaying for specs that don’t impact appearance.

The four Cs are grading factors traditionally used by gemmologist and expert jewelers to decide the quality and value of a diamond. They are Clarity, Color, Cut, and Carat Weight.

To learn more, check out this page on our website → Diamond Education: Our Perspective.

As with other characteristics from which a diamond is graded, the quality of the cut directly influences the level of fire and radiance when light reflects through a diamond. A well-cut diamond shines brighter and reflects white and dyed light back to you. A poorly cut diamond can look dull and lifeless compared to one executed by a master gem cutter.

For that, we believe the quantity of light return and luminance found in an expertly cut diamond is worth the extra investment.

All of our diamonds come from the recycled market which means Buchroeders Jewelers does not partake in any mining activities.

Our sister company Diamond Banc is the supplying force behind our loose diamonds, and a notorious competitive advantage in terms of pricing compared to our competitors.

While diamonds are widely available, high-quality diamonds, and unique color and clarity combinations are much rarer. At Buchroeders, we specialize in hand-selecting premium stones that meet strict standards for brilliance, cut, and certification.

Diamonds are formed deep within the Earth under extreme heat and pressure, then surface through volcanic activity over billions of years. At Buchroeders, we source ethically sourced, natural diamonds via the recycled market.

Diamonds from Buchroeders can be a smart long-term investment, especially when paired with our dollar-for-dollar upgrade privilege—allowing you to apply the full value of your original diamond toward a future upgrade at any time. This exclusive benefit helps your diamond purchase retain value over time. Please note, this policy does not apply to lab-grown diamonds, as their market value tends to decrease. Our team will help you choose the right diamond with both emotional and financial value in mind.

Diamonds are cut by skilled artisans using advanced tools to maximize sparkle and symmetry. At Buchroeders, every diamond we offer is precision-cut to highlight its natural beauty and value, ensuring exceptional quality in every piece.

Diamonds are made of pure carbon atoms arranged in a tight crystal structure, giving them unmatched hardness and brilliance. At Buchroeders, we offer both natural and lab-grown diamonds, each backed by trusted certifications and our expert guidance.

Not sure about other jewelers in Missouri but we certainly do! We offer financing options through Wells Fargo and Affirm.

For more info, click here.

Yes, it is because it’ll give you the peace of mind you deserve for an important purchase you just can’t miss out on! We offer an unmatched menu of flexible financing options for all types of credit profiles nationwide.

Yes. We offer convenient monthly payments to fit your budget with a user-friendly online account management tool so you can always keep abreast of any incoming bills. We provide several financing options for your convenience.

Buchroeders accepts jewelry financing requests from all types of credit profiles and processes them in a transparent, timely manner.

Yes! You can complete an online credit application and receive a decision in minutes. To review our financing options and apply online, please click here.

Yes, financing jewelry can affect your credit, as all financing options involve some level of credit check. At Buchroeders, we believe in full transparency and responsible shopping, which is why we clearly explain all available options. If credit is a concern, we also offer flexible in-store financing solutions—because we don’t want anything to stand between you and the piece that means the most.

At Buchroeders, financing jewelry is simple and stress-free. We partner with premier lenders like Wells Fargo and Affirm to offer flexible financing options, fast approvals, and low monthly payments. Whether you’re purchasing an engagement ring or a luxury timepiece, our financing solutions are designed to fit your budget—so you can focus on the moment, not the price tag.

Yes, Buchroeders offers easy payment plans for engagement rings, custom designs, and fine jewelry. Our in-house experts will walk you through all your options so you can buy now and pay over time.

Buchroeders offers some of the best jewelry financing in Columbia, MO, with multiple lenders, 0% interest plans, and flexible terms tailored to your budget and timeline.

Yes, they are. Our master bench jeweler, Jesse, and watch technician stay committed to our 125 years of quality craftsmanship promise.

Yes, we absolutely believe it’s worth it—especially when done by professionals. Proper jewelry and watch restoration can revive the fire, brilliance, and value of your piece. At Buchroeders, we’re proud to have Jesse the Jeweler, a master craftsman with over 25 years of experience on our team. Jesse has restored thousands of cherished pieces, combining expert skill with unmatched attention to detail to protect and enhance the long-term quality of your jewelry or timepiece.

Indeed, we're the best in the Midwest. Depending on the physical or mechanical condition of the jewelry or luxury watch in question, replacement pieces or parts required and other factors all play a role in determining the turnaround time.

Yes, and we adore seeing our customers' reactions every time! Our in-house bespoke jewelry designers love thinking outside the box by challenging their creativity and creating a refined, revived version of your precious handed-down family heirloom jewelry. We start by observing closely the original piece, come up with a drawn sketch for the new design idea, and reproduce a photorealistic version using 3D CAD technology to show you what it will look like in real life.

Yes! First, you simply have to fill out a form to set up your customer profile. Click “Get Pre-Approved with Affirm” and one of our experts will reach out to you so you may schedule a time to shop with us! Get started here.

Yes, of course. We provide full service for parts including dial replacement, watch batteries, or bracelet restoration for instance. When repairing a Rolex watch, we only use 100% genuine Rolex factory parts to ensure compliance with the manufacturer’s quality standards and ongoing performance.

Rolex repair costs typically range from $500 to $1,500, depending on the service needed, including labor and parts. Complete overhauls or tune-ups usually fall between $800 and $1,000. At Buchroeders, we offer clear, upfront estimates and expert care for every timepiece.

Yes, our expert repair team can restore your Rolex watch and make it look brand new again. If your timepiece is in a very bad condition, with shattered glass, broken internal pieces or not running at all, bring it in for a free repair estimation and that pleasurable thought of wearing your Rolex watch again!

Yes, Buchroeders offers quick and reliable watch battery replacement services at our Columbia, MO location. Our experts can service most watch brands while you wait—no appointment needed.

Yes, most jewelry cleaners can remove light tarnish, especially from sterling silver. For deeper tarnish or delicate pieces, Buchroeders offers professional cleaning services using safe, effective methods that restore your jewelry’s original shine without damage.

You should clean your jewelry every 1–2 weeks at home to prevent buildup of oils and dirt, and have it professionally cleaned every 6 months. At Buchroeders, we offer complimentary professional cleanings to keep your pieces sparkling and in top condition year-round.

Jewelry should be professionally inspected every 6 months to check for loose stones, worn prongs, or other damage. At Buchroeders, we offer free inspections to help protect your pieces and ensure your jewelry stays secure and beautiful.

You can sell your engagement ring or fine jewelry whether they are designer pieces or not. We are a heavy Rolex Buyer in the Midwest or other luxury watch brands like Cartier, Breitling, Omega and more. Diamond Banc, our national buying division, is conveniently headquartered within our store. Our industry experts are available on the spot to evaluate your diamonds, gold, silver or platinum jewelry, & high-end watches. We are a premier gold buyer and accept in bars, coins, and bullion.

When you trust Buchroeders, you’re working with an innovative team of in-house certified appraisers who carefully evaluate every value-adding detail of your jewelry. We conduct specialized tests to determine metal purity, authenticity of diamonds or gemstones, and identify hallmarks or designer markings—ensuring an accurate, transparent valuation every time.

Any type really as long as it’s worth something. Custom-made jewelry, vintage/special collection pieces or even family heirloom jewelry. Bring your old jewelry, even if it is broken or worn. Designer high jewelry is definitely welcomed as we work with leading industry experts who have serviced customers on the retail side at flagship stores such Tiffany & Co. and Harry Winston.

We accept yellow, white or rose gold, as well as platinum, titanium and sterling silver.

Yes, we do, Buchroeders is one of the leading diamond buyers in the country. When you think diamonds, think Buchroeders.

First of all, it’s important for you to know that our buying division is powered by our sister company Diamond Banc.

With a large network of qualified fine jewelry and Rolex buyers, rest assured your items are examined thoroughly in a value-driven, transparent and secured method. We take into account every value-adding factor to maximize the highest dollar for an appealing offer made just for you.

If you come in person and we have a market director on the spot, ready to assess your item(s), you can receive an offer within a few hours.

To sell jewelry near you, visit Buchroeders in Columbia, MO. We offer free evaluations, top market prices, and immediate payment for gold, diamonds, and designer pieces—no appointment needed. Walk in today or start with an online quote.

Some jewelry—especially pieces made with high-quality diamonds, gold, or designer brands—can hold or even increase in value over time. At Buchroeders, we help clients understand the resale potential of their jewelry and offer competitive purchase offers if you ever choose to sell.

Get immediate payment in cash, via check or wire transfer.

Yes, many jewelry stores buy rings—but not all offer the same value. At Buchroeders, we buy diamond rings, gold rings, and designer pieces, offering top prices, free evaluations, and immediate payment right here in Columbia, MO.

Gold prices change daily based on the market, measured per gram or ounce. At Buchroeders, we pay top dollar for gold based on the current market rate, whether you’re selling gold jewelry, coins, or scrap. Visit us in Columbia, MO for a free, no-obligation quote.