the price your diamonds deserve

Buchroeders offers a rewarding way to sell the diamond jewelry you no longer wear. We believe that clients should be treated with the same respect and enthusiasm when they wish to sell their diamond, as they received when they initially purchased it- regardless of where they purchased it in the first place.


Whether you are visiting us in person or inquiring to sell your diamond online, our process is the same. First, we will identify the specifications of your diamond. With this, we will show you compareable diamonds that are for sale on the largest dealer-to-dealer diamond trading platform and demonstrate how your diamond is evaluated. We will provide you with a written purchase offer and write you a check on the spot should you accept our offer.


But selling your diamond doesn't have to be. With 120+ years in the diamond and jewelry industry, we've built an extensive network of individuals, retailers and wholesalers to whom we sell thousands of pieces of jewelry to monthly. Our experience, expertise, and capital means that we can offer you exactly what your jewelry is worth. Simply put, we will beat any legitimate offer. Period.

Missouri’s Top Rated Diamond Buyers

When you are selling your diamond jewelry, engagement ring, or a loose diamond in Missouri, you desire to receive the highest amount you can for that piece. The determining factors of the value of a diamond include the diamond shape, clarity grades, carat weight, and color. Each of these factors makes up a significant portion of how the current liquid value of your diamond is found.

Other factors that can affect the value of a diamond include the types of treatment or enhancements particularly when a diamond has been subject to artificial enhancements it will generally decrease in value compared to if it had not been enhanced.

If you’re looking to sell your diamond to a reputable diamond buyer, look no further than Buchroeders Jewelers in Columbia, MO. With 1,000+ reviews on Google, we are the place that other people like you in Mid-Missouri have chosen to sell their diamonds. When selling your diamond jewelry, we have the expertise and resources to pay significantly more than any other diamond buyer. We are the exclusive consumer-facing diamond and jewelry buying partner of Diamond Banc, our sister company whose nationwide presence and reputation speaks for itself.

Our buying division is powered by our sister company, Diamond Banc, which operates out of our Columbia, MO office with over 9 Diamond Banc locations across the nation. This synergy allows us to offer you more when you are selling your diamond engagement ring or diamond jewelry. We pride ourselves in a well-oiled, data-driven buying process that will ensure you get the highest value when selling your diamond jewelry to us. Utilizing the most current and up-to-date market research to explain and evaluate your diamonds’ worth. This allows us to provide you the highest possible values for your diamond jewelry.

When we are buying diamonds that are 2CT+ or are from designers such as Tiffany & Co, Van Cleef & Arpels, Harry Winston and more, we have the expertise to recognize the value they possesses and in turn, we compensate you accordingly.

In conjunction with our data-driven, innovative, and educational buying process, Buchroeders Jewelers provides a selection of financial solutions that are personalized to you.

Sell Your Diamond Outright

This is a more traditional option when selling your diamond. The customers who want to be compensated in a monetary way for their diamond right away prefer this option. When buying diamonds, Buchroeders Jewelers will make you an offer that matches the true value of your diamond engagement ring or other diamond jewelry.

Trade-In Your Diamond

An alternative option to immediate purchase is to trade your diamond in for a more valuable diamond. If you’re ready to move on to a different diamond, this option and our diamond selection is perfect for you! If your diamond is from Buchroeders Jewelers and is a natural diamond, we offer a dollar-for-dollar Diamond Upgrade Priveldge program. This means that we will pay you exactly what you paid for you r diamond in the first place when you choose to upgrade your diamond engagement ring stone with us. For those who did not purchase a diamond from us, we still honor the trade-in commitment and will explain to you the true value of your diamond and offer accordingly.

When buying diamonds, it is important to note that the size of your diamond is not the most important factor. Here at Buchroeders Jewelers, we are the top choice for people selling their diamond in Mid-Missouri and nation-wide. If selling your diamond jewelry is something you are ready to do, stop by our store to get more information on the value of your diamond.

Buchroeders Jewelers Buying Division serves Mid-Missouri, including but not limited to: Boone, Jackson, Lafayette, Saline, Howard, Cass, Johnson, Pettis, Cooper, Moniteau, Morgan, Cole, Miller, Camden, Chariton, Randolph, Macon, Callaway, Osage, Gasconade, Montgomery, Warren, Lincoln, St. Charles, St. Louis, and Jefferson County.