Should I Buy a Lab Grown Diamond Engagement Ring?

If you're reading this, chances are you're on the cusp of making one of the most exciting and meaningful purchases of your life: an engagement ring. Gone are the days when your only option was a natural, mined diamond. Welcome to the new age, where lab-grown diamonds are making waves and giving us all a lot to think about. Yep, the diamond engagement ring landscape is evolving! While natural diamonds have been around for millennia, becoming deeply ingrained in our culture and traditions, lab-grown diamonds are rising stars in the world of fine jewelry. They're shaking up what we thought we knew about diamonds, and as you can imagine, they've become the center of a sparkly debate. On one side, there are those who admire the authenticity and uniqueness of natural diamonds. On the other hand, supporters of lab-grown diamonds highlight their affordability.

So, that brings us to the burning question: Should you buy a lab-grown diamond engagement ring? The answer isn't straightforward and depends on a myriad of factors—some of which you might not have considered yet. But by the end of this, we are sure you will know your answer.

six engagement rings in hand

How Do Lab Grown Diamonds Differ from Natural Diamonds?

While natural diamonds and lab-grown diamonds share identical physical and chemical traits, their origins are fundamentally different. Natural diamonds are created over immense spans of time—millions or even billions of years—making each one distinct and hard to come by. The journey of unearthing, extracting, and delivering these natural diamonds to consumers requires significant resources and time.

On the flip side, lab-grown diamonds are synthetically crafted, produced in bulk through advanced technologies that are constantly improving. As the production levels of these lab-made gems surge, the market gets flooded with them, causing their price tags to steadily drop. This, in turn, makes lab-grown diamonds more budget-friendly and accessible to a broader range of buyers.

The Benefits of Lab Grown Diamonds

Cost-Effectiveness: One of the most compelling advantages of choosing lab-grown diamonds is their cost-effectiveness. On average, lab-grown diamonds can be anywhere from 20% to 40% less expensive than their natural counterparts. This cost difference allows you to either save money or allocate your budget to getting a larger or higher-quality diamond than you might afford with a natural diamond. The lower price point doesn't compromise the diamond's quality; remember, lab-grown diamonds share the same physical and chemical characteristics as natural diamonds. The choice then boils down to how much sparkle you want for your buck!

Customization: Another appealing feature of lab-grown diamonds is their potential for customization. Since these diamonds are manufactured, it's easier to request specific shapes, sizes, and even colors during the production process. This allows you greater freedom in designing a custom engagement ring that reflects your unique tastes and preferences. For those who desire something one-of-a-kind, lab-grown diamonds offer an avenue to realize your dream ring in a way that may be more challenging with natural diamonds.

With cost savings and customization possibilities, lab-grown diamonds offer benefits that make them a compelling option for many consumers.


The Drawbacks of Lab Grown Diamonds

While lab-grown diamonds offer various advantages, it's crucial to also consider their drawbacks, especially when making a significant investment like an engagement ring. Here, we'll examine some of the limitations you should be aware of before taking the plunge.

Resale Value: One of the most significant downsides to purchasing a lab-grown diamond is its potential lower resale value. While these diamonds share the same chemical and physical characteristics as natural diamonds, they often don't hold their value as well in the secondary market. This is partly because lab-grown diamonds are becoming more accessible and affordable, causing the market to be saturated with them. Therefore, if you're considering selling your diamond down the line, you might find it has depreciated more than a natural diamond would have.

Perceived Authenticity: Another point of contention is the issue of perceived authenticity. For many people, part of the allure of a natural diamond lies in its unique formation over millions or even billions of years. This geological marvel adds an intrinsic value that some feel is missing in lab-created diamonds. The belief that natural diamonds are more 'real' or 'authentic' is prevalent among certain consumers, and it's something to consider if you or your partner value this authenticity.

Energy Consumption in Production: While lab-grown diamonds are often hailed for being more ethical in terms of sourcing, it's worth noting that their production can be energy-intensive. Advanced technologies like High Pressure High Temperature (HPHT) and Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) are used to create these diamonds, and these processes can consume a significant amount of electricity. Although the environmental impact varies depending on the specific methods and energy sources used, it's an important consideration if you're trying to make an eco-conscious choice. 

It’s worth noting that purchasing a natural diamond from the recycled market is by-far the most ethical and sustainable option when shopping for a diamond for your engagement ring. Buchroeders offers a diverse selection of natural diamonds, sourced from the recycled market. These recycled diamonds offer all the brilliance, durability, and allure of newly-mined stones but come with the added benefit of being an eco-friendlier choice. 

By keeping these drawbacks in mind—lower resale value, questions about authenticity, and energy consumption—you can make a more informed decision about whether a lab-grown diamond is the right choice for you. 

Hand holding engagement ring


Your Diamond, Your Choice

Choosing an engagement ring is an exciting yet monumental decision that should reflect your values, lifestyle, and budget. We've walked you through the labyrinth of considerations, from the cost-effectiveness and customization possibilities of lab-grown diamonds to their potential downsides like lower resale value and questions about authenticity.

Making an informed decision means weighing all these factors carefully. If budget and customization are top priorities for you, a lab-grown diamond offers undeniable advantages. On the other hand, if you value the idea of a diamond with a unique geological history or are thinking about the investment aspect, a natural diamond might be more up your alley.

Buchroeders is committed to informing our clients about the distinct characteristics of both natural and lab-grown diamonds. Our transparency extends to clearly communicating our company's standpoint. Regardless of your preference for a rare natural diamond or a widely produced lab-grown diamond, our mission is to provide you with the product and exceptional experience you deserve.

So, what's it going to be? A traditional natural diamond with its unique allure or a lab-grown diamond that aligns with modern sensibilities? Whatever you choose, make sure it's a decision that both you and your partner will be happy with for years to come.

Read The Lab-Grown Diamonds FAQ's

Explore Natural Proposal Ready Engagement Rings

Explore Lab-Grown Proposal Ready Engagement Rings

Schedule An Appointment

Contact Us