Our Perspective: Natural & Lab-Grown Diamonds

Understanding the World of Diamonds

Diamonds have long been celebrated for their beauty, durability, and significance in various aspects of life, especially when it comes to symbolizing commitment through engagement rings. Over time, two types of diamonds have emerged in the market, each with its unique set of attributes - natural diamonds and lab-grown diamonds. In this blog post, we will delve into the world of diamonds, exploring the similarities and differences between these two fascinating categories, and the realities each diamond type faces.

The Science behind Natural and Lab-Grown Diamonds

Natural Diamonds

Formed deep within the Earth's mantle over millions and billions of years, natural diamonds are the product of incredible geological processes. Each natural diamond is a marvel of nature, and its creation is a unique journey, making it rare and highly coveted. Unearthing and bringing these precious diamonds to market require significant investments of time, resources, and expertise.

Lab-Grown Diamonds

Also known as lab-created or synthetic diamonds, lab-grown diamonds are created in controlled environments that mimic the conditions under which natural diamonds are formed. Through advanced technological processes, scientists can produce these diamonds with identical physical and chemical traits to their natural counterparts. As production methods improve, the efficiency increases, leading to a surge in the number of lab-grown diamonds available, subsequently driving down their prices.

diamond engagement rings and loose diamonds

The Rarity Factor: A Critical Distinction

Natural Diamond Rarity

The allure of natural diamonds lies not only in their stunning beauty but also in their innate rarity, a characteristic that captivates the hearts of many. Unlike lab-grown diamonds, which are produced through controlled processes in laboratories, natural diamonds take millions to billions of years to form deep within the Earth's mantle. The remarkable journey that each natural diamond embarks on is a testament to the awe-inspiring forces of nature.

One of the primary factors that contribute to the allure of natural diamonds is their rarity. The larger the natural diamond, the exponentially rarer it becomes. For instance, a 2-carat natural diamond is approximately four times rarer than a 1-carat natural diamond. This scarcity directly influences their market value, making larger, high-quality natural diamonds extremely valuable and sought after.

While lab-grown diamonds offer an alternative for those seeking a more affordable option, they cannot replicate the millions of years of natural formation, the rarity, and the inherent connection to the Earth's history that natural diamonds embody. The mesmerizing journey of a natural diamond from deep within the Earth to adorning a cherished piece of jewelry is a testament to the beauty and wonder of the natural world.

Lab-Grown Diamond Abundance

In recent years, lab-grown diamonds have gained popularity as a viable alternative to natural diamonds. While lab-grown diamonds possess the same physical and chemical properties as their natural counterparts, they lack the inherent rarity and unique characteristics that make natural diamonds so highly prized.

One of the primary advantages of lab-grown diamonds is their abundance. Unlike natural diamonds, which are formed over millions of years through geological processes deep within the Earth, lab-grown diamonds can be produced in a matter of weeks or months, depending on their size and complexity. This accelerated production is made possible by advancements in diamond-growing technology, which has significantly increased the efficiency of the manufacturing process.

Mass-production capabilities further contribute to the abundance of lab-grown diamonds. As with any technology, increased production leads to lower costs, and the same applies to lab-grown diamonds. With each passing day, the number of lab-grown diamonds available in the market continues to rise, making them more accessible to a broader range of consumers.

lab-grown diamonds lack this inherent rarity and individuality. Due to their mass-production nature, growers can create lab-grown diamonds of any desired size with relative ease. While lab-grown diamonds may offer a visually similar appearance to natural diamonds, they lack the natural irregularities and captivating features found in their naturally formed counterparts.

Price of a one carat diamond quarterly

The Value Dilemma: Natural vs. Lab-Grown Diamonds

As mentioned earlier, the increased efficiency in lab-grown diamond production leads to lower prices. For example, a 5-carat E color, VVS2 clarity round lab-grown diamond might be priced around $30,000 as of July 2023. While this price point seems attractive, it is essential to consider the long-term value retention.

Natural Diamond Value Retention

Natural diamonds, owing to their rarity, tend to retain their value over time. Investing in a natural diamond means that if you decide to resell or upgrade it in the future, you are likely to realize a significant return on your investment. 

Buchroeders Diamond Upgrade Privilege: At Buchroeders, we offer a trade-in privilege for natural diamonds, allowing you to apply the full initial amount toward a more valuable natural diamond of your choice when upgrading. This privilege is not applicable toward Lab-grown diamonds.

Lab-Grown Diamond Value Retention

On the other hand, lab-grown diamonds do not retain notable resale value. As their supply continues to increase, the market becomes more saturated, making it challenging to command higher prices for lab-grown diamonds. The absence of genuine rarity in lab-grown diamonds hinders their value retention and limits the options for resale or trade-in privileges.

The Buchroeders Perspective: Educating and Empowering Our Clients

At Buchroeders, we prioritize the education of our clients and potential clients about the realities of both natural and lab-grown diamonds. We believe that making an informed decision is paramount when choosing a symbol of love and commitment. Whether you decide on a rare natural diamond or a mass-produced lab-grown diamond, our commitment to serving you remains unwavering.

engagement rings stacked on finger

A Choice from the Heart

In conclusion, the choice between a natural diamond and a lab-grown diamond ultimately comes down to personal preference and priorities. While lab-grown diamonds offer an affordable option for those seeking the look of a diamond at a lower price point, natural diamonds embody the wonders of nature and possess significant long-term value retention.

As you embark on the journey to find the perfect diamond engagement ring, we encourage you to explore both options and consider what resonates with your heart and values. Remember, each diamond, whether natural or lab-grown, carries its unique story, and it is that very story that will accompany you on your journey of love and commitment. At Buchroeders, we are here to guide and support you every step of the way. Happy diamond hunting!

Read The Lab-Grown Diamonds FAQ's

Explore Natural Proposal Ready Engagement Rings

Explore Lab-Grown Proposal Ready Engagement Rings

Schedule An Appointment

Contact Us