Great Advice For Buying Your First Diamond

When it comes to buying your first diamond, the significance of expert advice cannot be overstated. Making an informed decision that aligns with your preferences and budget is crucial in ensuring that your diamond purchase meets your expectations for quality and value. At Buchroeders Jewelers in Columbia, MO, we understand the importance of this decision, and we are here to be your trusted guide in the diamond buying process.

As a reputable source of high-quality diamonds, we take pride in offering our expertise to assist you in finding the perfect diamond for your ring or any other piece of jewelry. Our dedicated team of experts are well-versed in the intricacies of diamonds, from the different diamond shapes to the settings available. We understand that every customer has unique preferences and budget considerations, and our goal is to help you navigate through these choices with confidence. 

When you choose Buchroeders Jewelers, you can trust that you are in the hands of professionals who are committed to providing exceptional service and guidance. We believe that buying a diamond should be an enjoyable and rewarding experience, and our teamis dedicated to ensuring that your journey is smooth and satisfying. Whether you're a first-time buyer or an experienced collector, our diamond buying guide is here to assist you every step of the way. With our knowledge, expertise, and exquisite selection of diamonds, we are confident that together, we can find the perfect diamond that will exceed your expectations and create lasting memories for years to come.

The Defining Decision When Buying Your First Diamond 

When it comes to purchasing your first diamond, one decision stands out as a game-changer: choosing between a lab-grown diamond, moissanite, or a natural diamond for your engagement ring. In recent years, lab-grown diamonds and moissanite have gained immense popularity as viable alternatives to natural diamonds. When considering a custom engagement ring, these options provide captivating choices. Their beauty and brilliance are comparable to natural diamonds, making them excellent options for creating unique and personalized engagement rings that perfectly match your vision.

Choosing a lab-grown diamond or moissanite for your custom engagement ring opens up a world of possibilities. With a lab-grown diamond or moissanite, you have the flexibility to design a ring that reflects you or your partner's style and personality. Collaborating with a skilled jeweler, you can select the perfect lab-grown diamond or moissanite and choose from a variety of settings, metals, and design elements. Additionally, lab-grown diamonds and moissanite offer a wide range of shapes, sizes, and colors, ensuring that your custom engagement ring is as unique as your relationship. Embrace the affordability of a lab-grown diamond or moissanite and create a stunning custom engagement ring that will be cherished for a lifetime. Here are some pros and cons for each: 

Natural Diamonds


  • Rarity: Natural diamonds are treasured for their rarity, as they take billions of years to form deep within the Earth.
  • Uniqueness: No diamond is the same. Each natural diamond has its own unique set of characteristics and inclusions, which makes them one-of-a-kind and can add sentimental value.
  • Value Retention: They are often considered a timeless investment and tend to retain value over time. At Buchroeders, we offer a Diamond Upgrade Privilege that is exclusive to natural diamonds. This means that if at any point you choose to upgrade your diamond engagement ring, we will give you exactly what you paid towards the purchase of a more expensive diamond. You can find more information about our Diamond Upgrade Privilege HERE.


  • Cost:Natural diamonds are inherently limited in supply, as they are formed deep within the Earth over millions of years, while lab-grown diamonds and moissanite can be produced in controlled environments, allowing for mass manufacturing and greater availability, thus reducing their cost. This scarcity of natural diamonds, combined with the unique allure of their natural origin, contributes to their higher price in the market.
  • Environmental Impact:The mining process for natural diamonds can be resource-intensive and may have a significant impact on the environment. If this element of natural diamonds is a concern to you, it is worthwhile to find a jeweler who specializes in sourcing recycled natural diamonds, like we do! You can find more information about how we acquire our natural diamond inventory HERE.
  • Limited Customization: Unlike lab-created diamonds, natural diamonds cannot be customized, so finding the perfect diamond requires a more exhaustive search.

Lab-Grown Diamonds 


  • Availability:Lab-grown diamonds offer a reliable and consistent supply compared to natural diamonds, and can be produced on demand, ensuring a steady availability for consumers. 
  • Cost-effective:Lab-grown diamonds are typically more affordable compared to natural diamonds. The production process for lab-grown diamonds is highly efficient, allowing manufacturers to offer these diamonds at a lower price point. The accessibility makes lab-grown diamonds an attractive option for those seeking the aesthetic and brilliance of diamonds without the hefty price tag. 
  • Consistency and Customization: Lab-grown diamonds can be produced with specific characteristics and qualities, allowing for greater consistency in terms of color, clarity, and carat weight. This level of control allows consumers to choose a diamond that meets their desired specifications. These lab-created diamonds offer the opportunity for customization where consumers can select unique shapes and colors that may be rarer or more challenging to find in natural diamonds. 


  • Perceived Value and Market Acceptance: While lab-grown diamonds possess the same chemical and physical properties as natural diamonds, they still face skepticism and resistance from some consumers who perceive them as less valuable or less authentic. The market for lab-grown diamonds is still developing and
  • Consumer Awareness and Education:Lab-grown diamonds face the challenge of consumer awareness and education. Many people may still be unfamiliar with the concept of lab-grown diamonds and how they differ from natural diamonds. The lack of awareness can lead to confusion or misinformation, making it difficult for consumers to make informed purchasing decisions. Additionally, the terminology used to differentiate lab-grown diamonds from natural diamonds can further contribute to the confusion. 
  • Limited Historical Value: Natural diamonds have a rich history  and carry sentimental value associated with their formation over millions of years. Lab-grown diamonds, being a relatively new innovation, lack this historical and sentimental value. Some individuals may prefer natural diamonds precisely because of their connection to the earth’s geological processes. 



  • Affordability: Moissanite is a more affordable alternative to diamonds. It offers a similar sparkle and brilliance at a fraction of the price. This affordability makes moissanite an attractive option for those on a budget or looking to maximize their purchasing power. 
  • Brilliant Optical Properties: Moissanite exhibits exceptional optical properties, including high refractive index and strong light dispersion. These characteristics result in a gemstone that displays an intense brilliance and fire, creating a captivating and eye-catching appearance. The unique optical properties of moissanite make it stand out and offer a distinctive sparkle that can be appreciated by jewelry enthusiasts. 
  • Wide Range of Shapes and Sizes: Moissanite is available in a wide variety of shapes and sizes, offering versatility and options for jewelry designs. Whether you prefer classic round cuts, elegant princess cuts, or unique fancy shapes, moissanite can be found in various styles to suit different preferences. Additionally, moissanite is commonly available in larger carat sizes compared to diamonds, allowing for the creation of bold and statement pieces without breaking the bank. 


  • Color Perception: While moissanite is known for its brilliance, some individuals may perceive a slight difference in color compared to diamonds. Moissanite tends to exhibit a higher level of spectral colors, particularly in certain lighting conditions. Although this color dispersion is appreciated by many, some individuals may prefer the colorless appearance of diamonds. 
  • Limited Rarity and Cultural Significance: Moissanite, as a lab-grown gemstone, lacks the natural rarity and cultural significance associated with diamonds. Diamonds have a long-standing tradition and historical importance, often symbolizing special milestones. Moissanite’s relative abundance and recent introduction to the market may make it less appealing to those seeking a gemstone with a deeper sense of rarity. 
  • Market Resale Value: Moissanite typically has a lower resale value compared to diamonds. The market for moissanite is still developing, and its perceived value and demand may vary. When considering the potential for future resale, it’s important to note that moissanite may not retain its initial purchase value to the same extent as natural diamonds, which have an established and recognized market. 

Finding the Ideal Diamond Shape for Your Hand: Expert Tips

When it comes to selecting the ideal diamond shape that suits your style and personality, there are important technical aspects to consider. At Buchroeders Jewelers, we offer our expertise to help you navigate this decision, ensuring a knowledgeable and educational experience. Understanding the unique attributes of different diamond shapes is crucial, as they can appear distinct when worn on different hands. Each shape interacts with light in its own way, creating varying levels of brilliance and sparkle. Additionally, the proportions and dimensions of diamond shapes can affect how they complement different hand sizes and finger shapes.

For example, the classic round shape is renowned for its exceptional brilliance and versatility. Its symmetrical shape tends to suit a wide range of hand sizes and finger shapes, making it a popular choice. On the other hand, elongated shapes like the emerald or marquise can create an illusion of length, making them an excellent choice for those with slender fingers. The princess cut, with its square shape and sharp corners, can add a contemporary touch to any hand. 

When selecting a diamond shape, it's important to consider factors such as hand size, finger length, and shape. This will help you choose a shape that creates a balanced and harmonious aesthetic when worn. By taking these considerations into account, you can ensure that your chosen diamond shape not only reflects your personal style but also enhances the natural beauty of your hand. Consider seeking expert advice from jewelers, like Buchroeders Jewelers who can assist you in choosing the diamond shape that best compliments you! 

Image of hand with rings on finger. One being a lab-grown diamond engagement ring | Buchroeders Jewelers

Maximizing Your Budget: Insider Tips for Buying Diamonds

Setting a budget when buying a diamond is a practical and essential step in the process. At Buchroeders, we understand the importance of financial considerations and are here to provide practical advice to help you make an informed decision without compromising on quality or beauty. To set a budget for your diamond purchase, it's important to assess your personal financial situation and determine a comfortable spending range. Consider factors such as your savings, income, and other financial obligations. It's crucial to be realistic and ensure that your diamond purchase aligns with your overall financial goals. Understanding the factors that influence diamond pricing is also key. The carat weight, cut, color, and clarity– along with additional factors like diamond shape and certification, contribute to the overall price of a diamond. By understanding these factors and their impact on pricing, you can make informed decisions about where to allocate your budget. 

At Buchroeders, we firmly believe that the perfect diamond is attainable, regardless of your budget. Our extensive selection of diamonds encompasses a wide range of price points, ensuring that there is something for everyone. We are committed to helping you find a diamond that meets your preferences and budget without compromising on quality. Our knowledgeable team is here to assist you in navigating the factors that influence diamond pricing. We can help you prioritize carat weight, cut, color, and claritybased on your preferences and guide you towards options that offer the best value for your budget. With our expertise and commitment to customer satisfaction, we will ensure that you find a diamond that exceeds your expectations while staying within your financial means. Setting a budget and understanding diamond pricing are crucial steps in the diamond buying process. At Buchroeders, we are dedicated to providing practical advice and assistance to help you make an informed decision. With our belief that the perfect diamond is within reach for every budget, we invite you to explore our collection and experience the joy of finding a stunning diamond that meets both your desires and financial goals.

The Importance of Certified Diamonds: A Buyer's Guide

When it comes to purchasing diamonds, understanding the importance of certified diamonds is paramount. At Buchroeders, we educate our customers on the significance of diamond certification and the value it adds to their purchase. Diamonds certified by renowned laboratories like GIA (Gemological Institute of America) or IGI (International Gemological Institute) provide assurance of authenticity, quality, and lasting beauty.

Certification for diamonds involves a stringent grading process conducted by these reputable laboratories. These processes assess and document various aspects of a diamond, including carat weight, cut, color, and clarity, as well as other characteristics such as symmetry and fluorescence. By obtaining a diamond certification from GIA or IGI, customers gain confidence in the accuracy of the diamond's specifications and can make informed purchasing decisions. 

At Buchroeders, we take pride in our meticulously selected and certified diamonds. Each diamond in our collection undergoes a thorough examination and evaluation by these trusted laboratories. We prioritize authenticity and quality to ensure that our customers receive only the finest diamonds. Our collection includes certified diamonds from reputable organizations like GIA and IGI, ensuring accurate grading of the carat weight, cut, color, and clarity and long-lasting beauty and value of the gem.

When you choose Buchroeders, you can be confident that our diamonds are accompanied by reputable certifications from esteemed laboratories. We believe in providing our customers with the assurance and transparency they deserve when making such a significant purchase. With certified GIA diamonds and diamonds certified by IGI, we offer you the peace of mind that comes with knowing the authenticity, quality, and lasting beauty of your diamond.

Image of 3 loose round diamonds on hand starting from a larger carat weight to smaller | Buchroeders Jewelers

Trust Buchroeders Jewelers for Expert Advice

Getting expert advice is crucial when it comes to buying your first diamond. At Buchroeders Jewelers, we offer our expertise to help you make an informed decision that aligns with your preferences and budget. Our team understands the intricacies of diamonds from different shapes to settings, and we are committed to providing a knowledgeable and educational experience. 

Located in Columbia, MO, Buchroeders Jewelers offers a wide selection of diamond engagement rings. Our collection includes various styles and designs to suit your taste and budget. With our expertise and commitment to customer satisfaction, we can assist you in finding the perfect diamond engagement ring that fits all of your personal preferences.


Trust Buchroeders Jewelers to help you find or design your dream engagement ring.